Reviewing Peer Responses to Artwork

It was really hard to find someone who had done both projects, so my first response is split between two people! :-(

Benjamin Bolton – “The First AED200 Blog”

Project #1

1. When looking at Project #1: (Elements and Principles), did you agree with the element or principle the artist listed with the images? Did you see other elements and principles in the images?

I think all of his images were reflective of their corresponding words, but most of them could have worked for two elements/principles or more. I noticed that his photo for ‘line’ of the brick wall also can represent texture and shape. Also, his photo for ‘proportion’ of his cat Poofies (lol) displays a good example of emphasis since she is a focal point at the end of the hallway and sticks out a little because of her dark color.

2. When looking at Project #2: Where there any images in the Peer Blogs the same as your own? If yes, what were they? Where the reasons the image was selected the same or different as your own?

This person didn't do Project #2, but I chose someone else (Richard Cruz) for the review question below. 

3. Where there any images that your Peers selected that pique your interest now? If yes, what are they and what is your connection with them? What would you want to know about them?

In Project #1, I really liked the photo for ‘color,’ because it was a painting that reflected him as an artist. His organization of shape, line, and color are all a personal reflection of his perception of the elements/principles. I’d like to know more about why he chose certain colors or shapes and where the inspiration to create them originated from.


Richard Cruz - "My Very First Blog"


2. When looking at Project #2: Where there any images in the Peer Blogs the same as your own? If yes, what were they? Where the reasons the image was selected the same or different as your own?


We did not have any of the same images, because we went to different museums and saw different exhibitions. I think we both chose pieces of artwork that we connected with, felt inspired by, or reminded us of something in our personal lives. 


Maggie Hartig - "Self-Discovery Through Art"

1. When looking at Project #1: (Elements and Principles), did you agree with the element or principle the artist listed with the images? Did you see other elements and principles in the images?


Yes, I thought all of her images reflected their element and principle extremely well. A lot of the images definitely could have represented other elements and principles too. Her 'color' image also could have represented unity or shape and her 'variety' image easily could have been used for texture as well. Overall she did a really great job!

2. When looking at Project #2: Where there any images in the Peer Blogs the same as your own? If yes, what were they? Where the reasons the image was selected the same or different as your own?

Again, we didn't have any of the same images because we didn't go to the same museum or view the same exhibit. It seems like she chose images that inspired her or that seemed abstracted with bright colors that made the viewer interested. 

3. Where there any images that your Peers selected that pique your interest now? If yes, what are they and what is your connection with them? What would you want to know about them?

I was really interested in the painting Softly By Joanne Dumas. The color palette and line progression really gave a feeling of movement and rhythm that reflected the ocean. I love how the panel moved off of the wall in a really non-traditional way. I think a lot of people feel a connection with water. It evokes a tranquil and peaceful mood that seems comforting to the viewer. I would like to know more about the artist's perspective in creating this piece. 

5. What do you think about  the process of reading your peers reflection? Do you find this to be a valuable in your learning?

I think its very valuable to read our peers' reflections on what we are studying. It helps to give perspective, which is especially nice in an online class environment when everything is very individualized and based upon one's own perspective and opinions. 

6. Check your Blog and read comments posted by your Peers. Do you find their comments helpful?

I'm sure the comments will be helpful in either validating my responses or giving helpful criticism from another perspective.